Ask any American parent what they expect from a competitive youth soccer club and you will hear a variation of the following answer; “We want a club that focuses on player development – not just winning.”
This sounds good, but I suspect most American parents don’t know what they are talking about and are merely repeating marketing buzzwords said by every club in America. I contend that you must understand the club’s soccer philosophy [or lack thereof] as a crucial part of evaluating your child’s development.
What is philosophy in terms of soccer? The sportswriter Jed Davies sums it up nicely,
The club’s philosophy is a set of beliefs about how soccer should be played on the field tactically.
Soccer tactics are the strategy(-ies) employed by a team to defend, attack and everything in between (the two transitions of losing the ball and winning the ball).
Philosophy? Where did you learn such a big word? Of course, you can’t ask most (not all) American coaches what their club’s philosophy is. If you did ask the question, which I don’t recommend – the result would likely be one of the following; they will be clueless, the more savvy ones will likely rattle off some developmental marketing speak and/or worst, they will typecast you as the crazy soccer parent (which could negatively impact how they treat your child).
My recommendation – Play dumb, (which in my case is not particularly hard) and ask them a few of the following questions – using as non-threatening of a tone as possible.
- 1) Assuming my child plays [pick a position] when our team has the ball, what do you expect to see him/her doing and what are some of the things he/she should be thinking about [at this age]?
- 2) When our team loses the ball, and he/she is playing [pick a position] what do you expect to see him/her doing and what are some of the things he/she should be thinking about [at this age]?
- Bonus Questions
- 3) Are there specific things you expect to see them doing differently offensive and defensive transitions?
- 4) Are there specific offensive and defensive technical skills that my child should be mastering now in order to fit into this system as they get older?
- 5) Can you give me an example of some drills that you use during practice that focuses on those areas?
- 6) Are you familiar with any professional teams that share a similar philosophy?
Hold up – Do you know that feeling you get when a boss/spouse/or loved one says to you, “We need to talk”? Well, that is the feeling the coach or club director will get if you bombard them with all these questions. I suggest spreading them out over the course of a season. I find that the best time to chat with a coach is after a win and never after a loss. If nothing else, at least you will put them on notice that you are watching with a critical eye.
Why does this matter? It doesn’t if your child is just playing for fun.
However, clubs with clearly defined philosophies (and high expectations) typically have consistently better coaching.
Think about in business, the highest performing companies have coherent strategies and simple metrics for evaluating employee performance. This creates a culture where even the least experienced employees are empowered to exceed goals.
Absent a clear philosophy (and high expectations), there is no coherent club culture. This means that the quality of your child’s coaching is random – based more on the coach’s own disposition.
Simply put, that is why most (not all) parents say, “The value of their child’s training is tied almost exclusively to the coach that they happened to get.” This should not be the case.
My child is young, so we don’t care about tactics? The fact that there are only two goals and one ball during games means that tactics are a part of soccer at any age. Of course, tactics play a minor role during the foundation phase. For younger ages, skill acquisition is the most important. Therefore, for me, there is a central question.
Is the club ensuring that my child masters the basic technical skills (dribbling, first touch, juggling/aerial, turning/changing direction, receiving and passing, finishing and 1v1) that will allow him/her to successfully adapt to almost any soccer philosophy in the future?
For the most part, the answer to the above question is no – which is the inspiration behind Triangle Soccer.
Gotta love team sports – don’t let the wins fool you. In youth soccer, many clubs inherent great individual talents that carry the team through from victory to victory. The fault-lines are only discovered (by the naive) after the team is confronted by a team that is superior technically and whose players can execute their club’s tactical philosophy properly.